Europe Feared the Tomato as a Poison Apple for More Than 200 Years
The tomato reached Europe in the early 1500s and spent two centuries feared as a poison apple. Its nightshade family, poisonous leaves and one hostile herbal built the case. The fruit was innocent the whole time.
Key points
- For more than 200 years, much of Europe treated the tomato as a plant to admire and never to eat.
- The tomato came from the Americas.
- John Gerard made it worse.
For more than 200 years, much of Europe treated the tomato as a plant to admire and never to eat. It grew in gardens as an ornament with a warning attached. Its nickname in the 1700s was the poison apple. The fruit on a pizza today spent two centuries under suspicion, and the case against it was built on a bad family tree, one hostile book and a theory about dinner plates that historians still argue over.
Guilty by family
The tomato came from the Americas. The Aztecs ate it and called it tomatl, and Spanish expeditions carried seeds back to Europe in the early 1500s. In 1544 the Italian herbalist Pietro Andrea Mattioli gave the plant its first known European description, and his filing decision hurt it for centuries. He placed the tomato with the nightshades and the mandrake, a group tied to poison. Tomatoes do sit in the nightshade family, which includes the genuinely deadly belladonna. Their leaves carry toxic compounds. The ripe fruit is safe, but the family name stuck.
John Gerard made it worse. His 1597 Herbal, a standard plant book in England, called the whole plant rank and stinking, and the doubt spread. Tomatoes reached Britain around the 1590s and were grown there mainly as exotic curiosities well into the 1800s.
The plate theory, and the doubt on it
By the 1700s, many Europeans feared the tomato outright. One long told explanation blames the dinnerware of the rich. Aristocrats ate from pewter plates with a high lead content. Tomatoes are acidic, and the story says the acid drew lead out of the plate and into the food, so diners were poisoned by lead while the tomato took the blame. Smithsonian Magazine carried that account in its history of the feared fruit.
The same Smithsonian history, updated in 2025, carries the pushback. Joe Schwarcz of McGill University argues the amount of lead a tomato could pull from a plate would be trivial and could never make a diner sick. His simpler explanation matches the paper trail. The tomato looked like its deadly relatives, its leaves really are poisonous, and early writers said so in print. Fear did the rest.
The slow pardon
The fear was never total. Mattioli himself recorded tomatoes being eaten in Italy in the manner of eggplants, and southern Europe adopted the fruit long before the north trusted it. Around 1880, the rise of pizza in Naples helped push the tomato into wide European use. Recipes had circulated in print for decades before that, yet the rumors lingered into the 1800s in Britain and America.
So the poison apple was never poison. It was a safe fruit carrying a dangerous surname, described early by writers who lumped it with killers, and served in an age that trusted printed herbals more than its own kitchens. Two hundred years of fear ended the ordinary way. People ate it, nothing happened, and dinner won.