No, the Amazon Does Not Make 20 Percent of the World's Oxygen
Scientists put the Amazon share of world oxygen production at about 6 to 9 percent, and the forest breathes in nearly all of it. The net supply to the air is close to zero.
Key points
- The claim is everywhere: the Amazon rainforest makes 20 percent of the world's oxygen, so losing the forest means losing the air.
- Here is the real answer up front.
- The figure spread fast during the Amazon fires of 2019, repeated by leaders, celebrities and news outlets.
The claim is everywhere: the Amazon rainforest makes 20 percent of the world's oxygen, so losing the forest means losing the air. It sounds precise. It is wrong, and scientists have said so for years.
Here is the real answer up front. The Amazon produces roughly 6 to 9 percent of the oxygen made by photosynthesis on Earth. Then the forest uses nearly all of it itself. Its net contribution to the oxygen in the air hovers around zero.
Where the 20 percent came from
The figure spread fast during the Amazon fires of 2019, repeated by leaders, celebrities and news outlets. FactCheck.org traced the numbers scientists actually use. Yadvinder Malhi, an ecosystem ecologist at Oxford University, worked from a 2010 study that credits tropical forests with about a third of the photosynthesis done on land. The Amazon is about half of that, so it makes around 16 percent of the oxygen produced on land.
Land is only part of the picture. Ocean phytoplankton do about half of all photosynthesis on the planet. Add the oceans in and the Amazon share of the world total falls to about 9 percent on Malhi's count. Climate scientist Jonathan Foley, using his own earlier work, put it at about 6 percent. Gordon Bonan of the National Center for Atmospheric Research told FactCheck.org the two numbers sit in the same ballpark of uncertainty. Neither is anywhere near 20.
The forest breathes its own oxygen
Production is only half the ledger. A living forest also breathes. Malhi's team reckons trees inhale a little over half of the oxygen they produce through their own respiration. Most of the rest is used by microbes and other organisms that break down fallen leaves, dead wood and other debris on the forest floor.
Add both sides and the net effect is, in Malhi's words, around zero. Michael Coe, who directs the Amazon program at the Woods Hole Research Center, told National Geographic the 20 percent claim does not make physical sense on a simpler ground: air holds 21 percent oxygen but less than half a percent of carbon dioxide, the raw material trees turn into oxygen. There is not enough carbon dioxide passing through the forest to build a fifth of the world's oxygen supply.
The oxygen in the air was also not made this year, or this century. It built up over millions of years, much of it from ocean plankton. The atmosphere holds such a huge stock that no single forest feeds it day by day.
The forest still matters, for other reasons
None of this is an argument for clearing the Amazon. Scientists make the opposite point: oxygen was always the weakest reason to protect it. The forest stores a huge amount of carbon in its trees and soils. It drives rainfall across South America. It holds a large share of the world's land species. Those are measured facts, and they are enough.
The myth survives because it is simple and scary. The truth is less tidy and more interesting. The lungs label flatters the forest with a job it does not do, and hides the jobs it does.