Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
US

Charlotte, North Carolina: City Asks Judge to Dismiss Zarutska Wrongful Death Lawsuit, Citing Governmental Immunity

Charlotte filed a 34 page motion on Monday asking a Mecklenburg County judge to throw out the wrongful death lawsuit over the 2025 light rail killing of Iryna Zarutska, arguing that transit policing and security decisions are protected by governmental immunity.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Charlotte, North Carolina: City Asks Judge to Dismiss Zarutska Wrongful Death Lawsuit, Citing Governmental Immunity

Key points

  • The City of Charlotte has asked a judge to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23 year old Ukrainian refugee who was stabbed to death on a city light rail…
  • Zarutska was killed on August 22, 2025 aboard a Lynx Blue Line train run by the Charlotte Area Transit System, known as CATS.
  • The motion says the lawsuit challenges law enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security contractor oversight and public safety administration.

The City of Charlotte has asked a judge to dismiss the wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of Iryna Zarutska, the 23 year old Ukrainian refugee who was stabbed to death on a city light rail train in August 2025. In a 34 page motion filed on Monday, November 16 in Mecklenburg County Superior Court, city attorneys argue that governmental immunity under North Carolina law shields Charlotte from the claims, and they ask that the case against the city be dismissed with prejudice, which would bar the family from filing the same claims again.

Zarutska was killed on August 22, 2025 aboard a Lynx Blue Line train run by the Charlotte Area Transit System, known as CATS. Police charged Decarlos Brown Jr. with first degree murder in her death. Brown was later deemed incompetent to stand trial, according to The Guardian, and prosecutors have said the criminal case will not be dismissed because of the competency ruling.

What the city argues

The motion says the lawsuit challenges law enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security contractor oversight and public safety administration. The city contends that each of those activities is a governmental function protected by governmental immunity. It also invokes the public duty doctrine, which limits when a government agency can be held liable for failing to protect one person from a criminal attack.

In the filing, the city wrote: "The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by Decarlos Brown Jr. The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack." If any claims survive, the city argues that state law caps what it could owe Zarutska's estate at a cumulative 1 million dollars. No judge has ruled on the motion.

What the family alleges

Zarutska's uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, filed the lawsuit in August 2026 on behalf of her estate against the city and Professional Police Services, the private contractor that provides security for the transit system. The suit alleges that Charlotte failed to take reasonable and available safety measures. According to the filing as reported by Fox News, there was no security guard inside Zarutska's train car when she was killed, Brown boarded without a ticket or pass, and the light rail system runs without turnstiles or fare gates. The family argues that running a fare charging transit system is a proprietary function, not a governmental one, and that the city waived immunity.

Mediation failed before the filing

Attorneys for the family, the city and the security company met for a four hour mediation session earlier this month that ended without an agreement, according to court reporting by the Charlotte Observer carried by The Guardian. The city's motion, its first public response to the claims, followed that impasse. The claims against Professional Police Services are separate from the city's motion and are not decided by it.

A Mecklenburg County Superior Court judge will now decide whether the claims against Charlotte can proceed. The motion does not end the lawsuit, and no hearing outcome has been reported.

Timeline

  1. Aug 22, 2025Iryna Zarutska, 23, a Ukrainian refugee, is stabbed to death aboard a Lynx Blue Line train in Charlotte. Decarlos Brown Jr. is charged with first degree murder.
  2. August 2026Zarutska's uncle, Frank Scott Haskell, files a wrongful death lawsuit for her estate against the City of Charlotte and its transit security contractor, Professional Police Services.
  3. November 2026A four hour mediation session among the family, the city and the security company ends without an agreement, according to court reporting.
  4. Nov 16, 2026Charlotte files a 34 page motion in Mecklenburg County Superior Court asking a judge to dismiss the claims against the city with prejudice, citing governmental immunity and the public duty doctrine. No ruling has been reported.

Sources