Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
US

Honolulu, Hawaii: Judge Voids Wildlife Clearance for First Deep-Sea Mining Lease Sale off American Samoa

U.S. District Judge Jill Otake in Honolulu vacated the fisheries service clearance for the first U.S. deep-sea mining lease sale, finding the review left out the mining the leases are meant to allow. The sale is still scheduled for November 19.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Honolulu, Hawaii: Judge Voids Wildlife Clearance for First Deep-Sea Mining Lease Sale off American Samoa

Key points

  • A federal judge in Honolulu, Hawaii has thrown out the wildlife clearance behind the first deep-sea mining lease sale ever planned in United States waters, three days before the auction was due to…
  • The court found that the fisheries service violated the Endangered Species Act when it concluded that selling the seabed leases was not likely to adversely affect listed species.
  • The case turned on how the agencies defined the action under review.

A federal judge in Honolulu, Hawaii has thrown out the wildlife clearance behind the first deep-sea mining lease sale ever planned in United States waters, three days before the auction was due to open. In an order dated Monday, November 16, U.S. District Judge Jill Otake granted summary judgment to Fa'asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai'i and vacated the National Marine Fisheries Service letter of concurrence for the sale off American Samoa.

The court found that the fisheries service violated the Endangered Species Act when it concluded that selling the seabed leases was not likely to adversely affect listed species. The ruling does not cancel the sale itself. It removes a legal approval the sale relied on, and it leaves the administration to decide whether to press ahead with bidding scheduled for Thursday, November 19.

What the judge decided

The case turned on how the agencies defined the action under review. The Marine Minerals Administration, the Interior Department agency running the sale, defined the action as the lease sale alone, plus early survey work. It left out the exploration, testing, development and mining the leases are meant to make possible. The fisheries service accepted that definition and considered only the effects of the early surveys on listed whales, sea turtles, sharks, rays, coral and other species.

Judge Otake found that the service wrongfully adopted that overly narrow definition and did not even attempt to consider the effects of activity after the leases are issued. The order calls the service's cramped, expedited, informal consultation apparently unprecedented in the context of leasing on the Outer Continental Shelf. The record shows the service received the request for expedited informal consultation on January 16, decided on February 3 that it had enough information to begin, and issued its letter ten days later. The federal government asked the court to send the letter back for revision while leaving it in place. The court refused, called the error fundamental, and ordered judgment entered and the case closed.

What is at stake

The sale, listed as Lease Sale PACM-1, covers up to two leases for seabed minerals on the American Samoa Outer Continental Shelf, an area Hawaii News Now put at about 31 million acres. The leases would first allow preliminary surveying and could later allow mining of polymetallic nodules from the ocean floor. The order traces the sale back to an unsolicited request from Impossible Metals Inc.

Fa'asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai'i, represented by Earthjustice, filed the lawsuit on August 18, 2026. Seumalu Dr. Elora Raymond, cofounder of Fa'asao Amerika Samoa, said American Samoans share a profound cultural and spiritual bond with the ocean and are relieved by the ruling. Earthjustice attorney David Henkin told the Guam Daily Post: She wiped it out.

A second lease sale, in waters off the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam, is tentatively scheduled for December 16 and is the subject of a similar case pending in the same court. The first test comes on Thursday, when the November 19 auction is either held, postponed or withdrawn.

Timeline

  1. Aug 18, 2026Fa'asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council for Hawai'i, represented by Earthjustice, file their lawsuit against the fisheries service clearance.
  2. Nov 16, 2026U.S. District Judge Jill Otake grants summary judgment to the groups, finds the National Marine Fisheries Service violated the Endangered Species Act, and vacates its letter of concurrence.
  3. Nov 19, 2026Lease Sale PACM-1, the first U.S. deep-sea mining lease sale, is scheduled to be held for seabed minerals off American Samoa.
  4. Dec 16, 2026A second lease sale in waters off the Northern Mariana Islands and Guam is tentatively scheduled and is the subject of a similar case in the same court.

Sources