Appeals Court Blocks Trump Administration From Withholding $73.5 Million in New York Highway Funds
The Second Circuit ruled on Friday that the Transportation Department penalized New York under a commercial driver license requirement that was not clearly written in the rules then in force.
Key points
- A federal appeals court in New York struck down the Trump administration decision to withhold $73.5 million in highway funding from New York on Friday, ruling that the US Department of…
- The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit said the funding decision rested on a licensing requirement that was not clearly set out in the regulations then in force.
- The dispute began with an audit by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, which started an annual review of the commercial licensing program run by the New York Department of Motor…
A federal appeals court in New York struck down the Trump administration decision to withhold $73.5 million in highway funding from New York on Friday, ruling that the US Department of Transportation went beyond its legal authority when it penalized the state over commercial driver licenses issued to foreign drivers.
The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit said the funding decision rested on a licensing requirement that was not clearly set out in the regulations then in force. In its ruling, the court said the department action "runs afoul of fair notice principles, departs from the regulatory text, and underestimates the complexity of its supposedly 'common sense' requirement."
An audit, then a funding penalty
The dispute began with an audit by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, which started an annual review of the commercial licensing program run by the New York Department of Motor Vehicles in July 2025. In a final determination issued on April 16, 2026, the agency said 107 of 200 sampled records failed federal requirements. It identified 101 licenses that stayed valid beyond the expiry dates on the lawful presence documents the drivers had presented, and six further records in which it said verification of lawful presence had not been demonstrated. Bloomberg Law reported that some licenses carried expiration dates as much as eight years past the period for which the holders could show they were lawfully present in the United States.
The agency withheld $73,502,543, equal to 4 percent of New York allocations under the National Highway Performance Program and the Surface Transportation Block Grant Program for fiscal year 2027. It warned that continued noncompliance could bring an 8 percent withholding, estimated at about $147 million a year from fiscal year 2028, and possible decertification of the state commercial licensing program.
The court sides with New York
Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul challenged the decision, and the state Department of Motor Vehicles petitioned the Second Circuit for review on April 24. The state argued that its licenses complied with the rules in place when they were issued, that the drivers held lawful immigration status, and that the agency had applied a new requirement without fair warning. Circuit Judges Alison J. Nathan, Sarah A. L. Merriam and Matthew A. Schwartz heard arguments on September 28.
Judge Nathan wrote the opinion, and Judge Merriam signed on to it. The court agreed with New York that the agency decision was arbitrary and capricious, noting that the agency itself concedes the plain text of the federal regulations in place during the relevant period did not contain an expiration matching requirement. The judges also noted that the audited license transactions took place before an interim rule issued on September 29, 2025, and were governed by the earlier regulatory text. The court stressed that it was deciding the legality of the funding penalty itself, not declaring that every challenged license satisfied all federal requirements. The case is State of New York v. U.S. Department of Transportation, Second Circuit, No. 26-1097.
What the ruling means
The decision restores funding for road and bridge work across the state. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and Administrator Derek Barrs had framed the penalties as a safety measure. Spokespeople for Duffy and for Hochul did not immediately comment on Friday.
The ruling could also shape a parallel California fight, where the administration withheld about $160 million over the same dispute and a Washington appeals court is weighing that case.
Timeline
- July 2025The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration begins an annual review of New York commercial driver licensing program.
- Sep 29, 2025The Transportation Department issues an interim rule. The licenses later audited were issued before it and governed by the earlier regulatory text.
- Apr 16, 2026The agency issues its final determination, says 107 of 200 sampled records failed federal requirements, and withholds $73,502,543 in highway funding.
- Apr 24, 2026New York and its Department of Motor Vehicles petition the Second Circuit for review of the funding decision.
- Sep 28, 2026Circuit Judges Alison J. Nathan, Sarah A. L. Merriam and Matthew A. Schwartz hear arguments in the case.
- Nov 13, 2026The Second Circuit invalidates the withholding, ruling that the department relied on a requirement not clearly established in the rules then in force.
Sources
- Reuters: Trump cannot withhold highway funding from New York, court says
- Bloomberg Law: NY Prevails in Noncitizen Commercial License Clash With Trump
- QNC News: Appeals Court Blocks Trump Administration Move to Withhold 73.5 Million Dollars in New York Highway Funds
- BarsAcross: New York Prevails in Appeal Against Federal Highway Funding Sanction