Kahului, Hawaii: Maui Police Commission Keeps Chief Pelletier on Paid Leave and Opens a Second Investigation
Commissioners voted 6 to 1 in Kahului to deny Chief John Pelletier's reinstatement, then voted 7 to 0 to investigate his October 9 press conference claims. His attorney says a lawsuit could come next week.
Key points
- Maui Police Chief John Pelletier will stay on paid leave, and the investigation around him just got wider.
- More than two dozen supporters and critics testified for about four hours during a meeting that ran almost seven hours.
- Commission Chair Frank Tam defended the leave.
Maui Police Chief John Pelletier will stay on paid leave, and the investigation around him just got wider. The Maui Police Commission voted 6 to 1 on Wednesday in Kahului to deny his request for reinstatement, then voted 7 to 0 to open a second independent investigation, this one into statements Pelletier made at an October 9 press conference and in later media appearances.
A seven hour meeting and an ultimatum
More than two dozen supporters and critics testified for about four hours during a meeting that ran almost seven hours. Near the end, Pelletier's attorney, Eric Seitz, told commissioners to reinstate the chief or face a lawsuit. Seitz argued that the Maui County Charter required a hearing before Pelletier was placed on leave, and that the commission discussed the move in executive session without specifying the evidence against him. He told reporters afterward that he could file suit as early as next week.
Commission Chair Frank Tam defended the leave. Tam said the commission saw a need to protect the integrity of the investigation in the face of serious federal criminal corruption charges against the head of the Criminal Intelligence Unit, a unit that reported directly to the chief. Tam also stressed that the commission is not alleging the chief did anything wrong, and that the point of the leave is to keep the investigation clean and to keep officers from feeling pressure when they are questioned.
The case underneath
Pelletier has been on paid leave since October 7, when the commission voted to sideline him while it investigates his oversight of the Criminal Intelligence Unit. The unit's commander, Lt. Michael Vaituulala, was arrested in August on federal bribery charges. Prosecutors allege he protected drug traffickers, organizers of chicken fights and importers of illegal fireworks. The commission has hired the law firm Littler Mendelson to run the first investigation, which is expected to take six months and could cost more than $50,000 under its contract.
The second investigation will decide whether Pelletier's October 9 statements amount to general order violations that could warrant disciplinary removal. At that press conference in Honolulu, Pelletier claimed commissioners had been pressured by Mayor Richard Bissen and linked his leave to criminal investigations involving the mayor. Bissen and Tam have denied that the mayor influenced the decision, and Prosecuting Attorney Andrew Martin has denied that the mayor is under investigation. On Wednesday, Seitz softened the claim, telling reporters he did not know who was being investigated or the scope of any inquiry.
Support, criticism and what comes next
Former commission chair Stacey Moniz spoke for Pelletier, citing his positive evaluations and department changes that included naming the department's first woman assistant chief. Retired Deputy Chief Dean Rickard backed the independent investigation, saying accountability and fairness have to go together. Some testifiers questioned whether commissioners who donated to Bissen's campaigns could be impartial. The mayor's communications director, Laksmi Abraham, said support for one candidate does not equate to opposition to another and repeated that Bissen did not influence the commission.
Pelletier declined to comment after the meeting. The commission's next regular meeting is set for December 16, 2026, and the chief remains on paid leave while both investigations run.
Timeline
- Aug 2026Lt. Michael Vaituulala, head of the Maui Police Department Criminal Intelligence Unit, is arrested on federal bribery charges.
- Oct 7, 2026The Maui Police Commission places Chief John Pelletier on paid administrative leave while it investigates his oversight of the unit.
- Oct 9, 2026Pelletier holds a press conference in Honolulu alleging pressure from Mayor Richard Bissen, and his attorney demands reinstatement in a letter to the commission.
- Nov 18, 2026The commission votes 6 to 1 to keep Pelletier on paid leave and 7 to 0 to open a second independent investigation into his October 9 statements.
- Dec 16, 2026The commission's next regular meeting is scheduled.
Sources
- Maui Now / Hawaii Journalism Initiative: Investigation against Maui Police Chief Pelletier widens as his attorney threatens lawsuit
- Maui Now: Maui Police Commission votes against reinstating the chief during temporary investigation
- Hawaii News Now: Maui police chief's attorney to file lawsuit after commission vote