Boise, Idaho: Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger Resigns After Guilty Plea in Elk Case
Governor Brad Little accepted the resignation on Wednesday, effective immediately, nine days after Harshbarger agreed to plead guilty to two misdemeanor hunting charges from a December 2025 elk hunt in Fremont County.
Key points
- Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger has resigned, and Governor Brad Little accepted the resignation on Wednesday, November 18, ending his service on the commission effective…
- Harshbarger represented the Upper Snake Region on the seven member commission, whose members are appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Idaho State Senate.
- On November 9, Harshbarger agreed to plead guilty to two of the seven misdemeanor charges filed against him: hunting without a valid tag, and shooting from or across a public highway.
Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger has resigned, and Governor Brad Little accepted the resignation on Wednesday, November 18, ending his service on the commission effective immediately. The governor's chief of staff, Zach Hauge, confirmed the end of Harshbarger's service in a letter to the commissioner, and the governor's office is already working to identify a replacement for the vacant seat, KTVB reported.
Harshbarger represented the Upper Snake Region on the seven member commission, whose members are appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Idaho State Senate. The commission sets hunting, fishing and trapping seasons, bag limits and other wildlife rules across Idaho, based on research and recommendations from Idaho Department of Fish and Game staff. He was appointed in 2024.
The plea agreement
On November 9, Harshbarger agreed to plead guilty to two of the seven misdemeanor charges filed against him: hunting without a valid tag, and shooting from or across a public highway. Under the agreement, prosecutors will dismiss the other five charges, including two counts involving the unlawful taking or killing of big game, and charges of hunting with the aid of a motorized vehicle, failing to make reasonable efforts to retrieve game, and trespassing.
The case began with a December 2025 hunt in Fremont County, near the Spring Hollow boat ramp. According to court documents cited in reporting on the case, Harshbarger and another hunter, Eric Murphy, were involved in shooting two elk, a six point bull on private property and an antlerless bull on federal Bureau of Reclamation land. Investigators alleged the hunters fired across a public road, that Harshbarger had no valid elk tag because he had already filled his tag on an earlier hunt, and that one elk was not properly retrieved. The investigation opened after a tip reached the department through its Citizens Against Poaching line in December.
The plea agreement calls for fines of up to $500 on each of the two charges, court fees, a one year revocation of his hunting privileges, and six months of probation on each charge, to run at the same time. Sentencing is scheduled for December 9, 2026, in Fremont County, where a judge will address the proposed penalties.
Pressure to step down
Harshbarger had stepped away from commission duties while the case proceeded and had not attended commission meetings since it opened, but he had not resigned and the governor had not removed him as of Tuesday, when his profile had already been removed from the commission website. On November 17, Republican State Representative David Leavitt publicly called on Governor Little to remove him, arguing that officials who write wildlife rules must answer for breaking them. The resignation was accepted the following afternoon.
The empty seat leaves the Upper Snake Region without a voice on the commission until the governor names a replacement and the Senate confirms the pick. Harshbarger's sentencing on December 9 will close the criminal case, but the appointment fight starts now, in a state where elk hunting rules are argued about in nearly every small town coffee shop.
Timeline
- Dec 20, 2025The Fremont County elk hunt at the center of the case takes place, according to the Idaho Capital Sun report of the charges.
- Nov 9, 2026Harshbarger agrees to plead guilty to two of seven misdemeanor hunting charges, with the other five to be dismissed.
- Nov 17, 2026State Representative David Leavitt publicly calls on Governor Little to remove Harshbarger from the commission.
- Nov 18, 2026Governor Little accepts Harshbarger's resignation, effective immediately, and his office begins the search for a replacement.
- Dec 9, 2026Sentencing is scheduled in Fremont County on the two charges covered by the plea agreement.