Congress Demands Answers After Navy Relieved USS South Dakota Command Team in October
Two senior House Democrats say the Navy never told Congress that the submarine's commanding officer, executive officer and chief of the boat were all relieved on Oct. 14, and they want the facts by Nov. 20.
Key points
- Two senior House Democrats say they are deeply frustrated that Congress was never notified when the command team of the attack submarine USS South Dakota was relieved last month.
- Reps.
- The letter says the commanding officer, the executive officer and the chief of the boat of USS South Dakota (SSN 790) were all relieved on Oct. 14, 2026.
Two senior House Democrats say they are deeply frustrated that Congress was never notified when the command team of the attack submarine USS South Dakota was relieved last month.
Reps. Joe Courtney of Connecticut and Adam Smith of Washington sent the letter on Thursday to Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao and Adm. Daryl Caudle, the chief of naval operations. Courtney is the ranking member of the House Seapower and Projection Forces Subcommittee, and Smith is the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee.
The relief on Oct. 14
The letter says the commanding officer, the executive officer and the chief of the boat of USS South Dakota (SSN 790) were all relieved on Oct. 14, 2026. A relief of a full command triad, the top three leaders of a submarine, is rare, and the lawmakers say the Navy has a long custom of telling Congress about at sea incidents, accidents and triad reliefs, even though no law requires it.
The Navy has confirmed only part of that account in public. The public affairs office for Commander, Submarine Force Atlantic confirmed that the commanding officer was relieved on Oct. 14, the letter says. Military Times reported the three names as Cmdr. Daniel Goodwin, Lt. Cmdr. Jacqueline Penichet and Senior Chief Information Systems Technician (Submarines) Jon Nogaj. The Maritime Executive reported that the Navy confirmed Goodwin's removal in a statement on Tuesday, citing a loss of confidence, and did not confirm a grounding or the other two reliefs.
South Dakota is a Virginia class attack submarine commissioned in 2019 and homeported in Groton, Connecticut.
A reported grounding the Navy has not confirmed
The lawmakers say the reliefs were allegedly attributed to a grounding incident. That word, allegedly, runs through every public account so far. The Navy has not confirmed that a grounding happened, has not said why the triad was relieved, and, as of the letter, had not given the committee an official notification of the details.
The Maritime Executive reported that the reported grounding took place sometime in September. It also reported a Navy commendation awarded on Oct. 6 to a navigation seaman, Ben Boyce, whose citation said he recognized that shoaling water presented an immediate hazard during maneuvers and warned the watch team early. The citation did not mention a grounding. Sources close to the matter told USNI News the submarine had a soft grounding toward the stern, The Maritime Executive said, a claim the Navy has not confirmed.
How Congress found out
Congress did not learn any of this from the Navy. On Nov. 11, a reporter asked about the dismissal of the command triad, the letter says. An article was published on Nov. 12, including the Submarine Force Atlantic confirmation. By then, nearly a month had passed since the reliefs.
Courtney and Smith pointed to past cases where the Navy did notify Congress, including the collisions involving USS Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain and the groundings of USS Hartford and USS Connecticut. They said the failure to notify raises questions about the Navy's commitment to transparency and accountability.
Seven questions, due Nov. 20
The letter asks the Navy to answer seven questions by Nov. 20: what led to the reliefs, whether a grounding or another mishap caused them, the cost and structural damage of any grounding, the maintenance timeline, any injuries, and why Congress was not notified.
Until the Navy answers, what happened to the submarine in September, and why its top leaders were removed in October, remain unconfirmed in public.
Timeline
- Sep 2026A reported grounding incident involving USS South Dakota takes place sometime in September, according to The Maritime Executive. The Navy has not confirmed a grounding.
- Oct 14, 2026The Navy relieves the submarine's commanding officer, executive officer and chief of the boat, according to the Courtney and Smith letter.
- Nov 11, 2026A reporter asks the Navy for comment on the dismissal of the command triad, the first notice Congress receives, according to the letter.
- Nov 12, 2026An article is published with Submarine Force Atlantic confirming the commanding officer's relief, and Courtney and Smith send their letter to the Navy.
- Nov 20, 2026Deadline the lawmakers set for the Navy to answer their seven questions.
Sources
- Rep. Joe Courtney: Letter to Navy, Courtney, Smith Express Deep Frustration Over Failure to Notify Congress of USS South Dakota Command Triad Relief
- Military Times: USS South Dakota command triad fired, draws ire of congressmen
- The Maritime Executive: U.S. Navy Removes Command Triad From Attack Sub After a Reported Grounding