Scottsdale, Arizona: Teen Arrested After Gunfire at a Short-Term Rental Hit Nearby Homes
Scottsdale police arrested an 18-year-old Apache Junction man on November 9 over gunfire that broke out on October 11 outside a south Scottsdale rental, sent bullets into nearby homes and left an infant's crib across the street from a bullet hole.
Key points
- Scottsdale police have arrested an 18-year-old man from Apache Junction in connection with gunfire that broke out in the early morning of October 11 outside a short-term rental in south…
- Police arrested Matthew Lee Simcox on November 9 in Apache Junction.
- The shooting happened at a rental on East Papago Drive near North 72nd Place and East Roosevelt Street.
Scottsdale police have arrested an 18-year-old man from Apache Junction in connection with gunfire that broke out in the early morning of October 11 outside a short-term rental in south Scottsdale, hit nearby homes and added to a long running fight in the city over problem rentals.
Police arrested Matthew Lee Simcox on November 9 in Apache Junction. He faces charges of endangerment, disorderly conduct and illegally discharging a firearm, and he is held in the Maricopa County jail on a cash only bond of $250,000, according to jail records reported by the Arizona Republic. The charges are allegations, and Simcox is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Bullets across Papago Drive, and a crib across the street
The shooting happened at a rental on East Papago Drive near North 72nd Place and East Roosevelt Street. A probable cause statement filed in Maricopa County Superior Court says 15 to 20 gunshots were fired from the front porch, the yard and the street around the rental, and at least seven people in the area called 911. FOX 10 reported that investigators recovered 58 spent cartridge casings across the porch and the street.
No one was injured. That was luck, neighbors and prosecutors say. A resident told police a bullet passed close by their head. FOX 10 reported that three bullets struck the home across the street, puncturing the roof and an exterior wall directly opposite a crib where an infant was asleep. The Arizona Republic reported that one bullet lodged in the wall of a home where an infant was sleeping. Police say Ring camera footage from the rental showed several males and females coming onto the front porch, several of them carrying firearms, including handguns and a rifle. Police said Simcox's brother's name was on the rental contract.
Court dates on November 17 and 19
At Simcox's initial appearance on November 10, his attorney, Carissa Jakobe, said he is a recent graduate of Skyline High School in Mesa, played varsity football, has a full-time job and is not a threat to the community. Prosecutors had asked for a $350,000 cash only bond, pointing to the danger of the gunfire and the infant's close call. A judge set the bond at $250,000. FOX 10 reported that Simcox is scheduled for a status conference on November 17 and a preliminary hearing on November 19.
Police said the investigation is still open and detectives are working to identify and locate other people involved in the shooting.
A rental problem the city counts in hundreds of calls
The October 11 shooting landed in a city already counting short-term rental calls by the hundreds. City officials said Scottsdale police received 665 calls for service at short-term rentals between January and August 2026, including 238 between June and August, and the city has about 2,966 active short-term rental licenses. Scottsdale runs a rental enforcement team that brings in the Police Department, the City Attorney's Office, code enforcement and other departments.
After the October shooting, Police Chief Joe LeDuc said the department has a proven track record of identifying and arresting those who come into Scottsdale and commit violent crimes. The Simcox arrest, announced in reporting on November 13, is the latest test of that claim, and police say it will not be the last arrest in the Papago Drive case.
Timeline
- Oct 11, 2026Gunfire breaks out in the early morning outside a short-term rental on East Papago Drive in south Scottsdale. Bullets hit nearby homes, no one is injured, and at least seven people call 911.
- Oct 16, 2026Scottsdale highlights its short-term rental enforcement after the shooting, and Police Chief Joe LeDuc says the department has a proven track record of identifying and arresting people who commit violent crimes in the city.
- Nov 9, 2026Scottsdale police arrest Matthew Lee Simcox, 18, in Apache Junction in connection with the October 11 gunfire.
- Nov 10, 2026At Simcox's initial appearance, a judge sets a cash only bond of $250,000. His attorney says he is a recent Skyline High School graduate with a full-time job.
- Nov 17, 2026A status conference is scheduled in Simcox's case, followed by a preliminary hearing on November 19, FOX 10 reported.