Phoenix, Arizona: DNA Under a Dead Man's Fingernails Leads to a Murder Charge at a Care Facility
Phoenix police arrested Brian Tapia, 43, on a second-degree murder charge after forensic testing tied his DNA to John Solomon, 60, who died days after a July assault at the Olive Grove care facility near Indian School Road.
Key points
- Phoenix police have arrested a care facility resident on a second-degree murder charge, five months after a fellow resident died of blunt force trauma injuries, and court records say DNA found…
- Brian Tapia, 43, was arrested on November 12 and accused of second-degree murder in the death of John Solomon, 60.
- On July 2, at about 5:10 a.m., Phoenix police responded to a report of an aggravated assault at the facility, near 30th Street and Indian School Road.
Phoenix police have arrested a care facility resident on a second-degree murder charge, five months after a fellow resident died of blunt force trauma injuries, and court records say DNA found under the dead man's fingernails is what tied the case together.
Brian Tapia, 43, was arrested on November 12 and accused of second-degree murder in the death of John Solomon, 60. Both men lived at the Olive Grove Memorial Care Facility near Indian School Road and 32nd Street in Phoenix, court documents said. Tapia was booked into jail and held on a $1 million cash-only bond, according to court records. He was due back in court on November 19. The charge is an accusation, and Tapia is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
The July 2 assault
On July 2, at about 5:10 a.m., Phoenix police responded to a report of an aggravated assault at the facility, near 30th Street and Indian School Road. Officers found Solomon with serious injuries, and he was taken to a hospital. He died of his injuries on July 8, Phoenix police Commander Mercedes Fortune said in a media advisory, and his death was investigated as a homicide.
A witness called 911 and told police blood could be seen on the floor and walls near the community room, according to court documents. Tapia was seen leaving the community room and was heard saying, "It is not my fault, he bit me first, he came to my room," the documents said. One witness told police Tapia was seen standing over Solomon and said he did not want to go back to prison over this, according to the documents. No witness and no surveillance video captured the assault itself, police wrote in their report.
What Tapia told police, and what the DNA showed
Investigators interviewed and detained Tapia early in the case. Officers saw a large amount of blood in front of his apartment, on the exterior door and on several pairs of his shoes, according to court documents. Tapia denied assaulting Solomon. He told police a different man had fought with Solomon and that he chased that man out. He said he tried to pick Solomon up and put him back in his wheelchair but could not, and that he went back to his apartment intending to call 911 but fell asleep before doing so, according to the documents.
Tapia told police he had been struck several times in the face during an altercation with a different man and had a cut to his eyebrow. Photos of his face did not show a cut or injury there, investigators wrote, though he had one on his finger and what appeared to be scratch marks on his neck.
Forensic analysis later showed Tapia's DNA was underneath Solomon's fingernails and on a piece of clothing that had been torn off, court records said. Investigators reported that no DNA tied the man Tapia said he chased away to the forensic evidence. After his November 12 arrest, Tapia maintained his original account of the incident, according to police.
Police have not released details on what led up to the assault, or on what contact the two men had before that morning.
Timeline
- Jul 2, 2026At about 5:10 a.m., Phoenix police respond to an aggravated assault at the Olive Grove care facility near Indian School Road and find John Solomon, 60, seriously injured.
- Jul 8, 2026Solomon dies of his injuries at a hospital, and Phoenix police investigate his death as a homicide.
- Nov 12, 2026Police arrest Brian Tapia, 43, a fellow resident, on a second-degree murder charge after forensic testing finds his DNA under Solomon's fingernails, court records say.
- Nov 19, 2026Tapia, held on a $1 million cash-only bond, is due back in court.