Oklahoma City, Oklahoma: State Farm Agrees to $45 Million Settlement Over Denied Roof Claims
State regulators say State Farm improperly denied or failed to pay wind and hail roof claims. The deal reopens claims closed without payment from 2021 through 2025 and sends $10 million to a fortified roof program.
Key points
- The Oklahoma Insurance Department announced on Friday, November 13, that State Farm agreed to a settlement worth more than $45 million after a state examination found the insurer improperly denied…
- Under the settlement, State Farm will set aside a minimum of $35 million to make affected consumers whole, contribute $10 million to the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program, and pay $2.86 million in…
- The examination reviewed claim files with loss dates from January 1, 2019 through December 31, 2024, The Oklahoman reported.
The Oklahoma Insurance Department announced on Friday, November 13, that State Farm agreed to a settlement worth more than $45 million after a state examination found the insurer improperly denied Oklahoma homeowners' wind and hail roof claims.
Under the settlement, State Farm will set aside a minimum of $35 million to make affected consumers whole, contribute $10 million to the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program, and pay $2.86 million in fines and expenses to the department.
What the examiners found
The examination reviewed claim files with loss dates from January 1, 2019 through December 31, 2024, The Oklahoman reported. Examiners counted 4,674 wind and hail roof claims closed without payment in that period and picked 181 claims for close review.
The department sent independent engineers to inspect roofs in person, instead of relying only on paperwork. Engineers completed inspections on 58 roofs and concluded that 27 had storm damage severe enough to warrant repair or full replacement. The sample produced 22 errors among the 58 reviews, an error rate of 12.15 percent, above the department's 7 percent tolerance threshold.
The department said that in at least 22 instances from November 1, 2023 through December 31, 2024, State Farm failed to comply with the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, and cited three cases where required written denial notices were not provided.
"We weren't willing to simply take State Farm's word for how these claims were handled," Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready said. The department, he said, put "independent engineers in the field to inspect roofs," an approach no other state had taken in a traditional examination.
How the reopening works
State Farm will pay for a reopening process for homeowners whose wind or hail claim had a loss date between January 1, 2021 and December 31, 2025 and was closed without payment, including people who got a partial payment or were placed under the deductible.
An independent claims administrator, chosen jointly by the department and State Farm, will review each claim file and any new documents homeowners submit. If the administrator finds the claim qualifies, State Farm pays under the policy terms. If qualifying claims cost more than the $35 million set aside, State Farm and the department will agree on additional funds. State Farm will mail department approved notices telling eligible homeowners how to opt in.
"I cannot stress enough how important it is for eligible homeowners to take advantage of this opportunity and opt in," Mulready said.
The $10 million for Strengthen Oklahoma Homes pays for fortified roofs, and the department said homeowners who install one save an average of $700 on premiums.
State Farm disputes the findings
State Farm said it disagrees with the examination's findings and denies any wrongdoing. "A limited review of individual claims should not be mistaken for a complete picture of our overall claims-handling practices," the company said. State Farm said it serves more than 530,000 policies in Oklahoma and has paid more than $2 billion for wind and hail damage there since 2024.
Commissioner-elect Bob Sullivan, who takes office in January, told The Oklahoman the conclusions match concerns he heard statewide.
The settlement closes only the department's regulatory case. It does not settle private lawsuits homeowners have filed against State Farm over roof claims, The Oklahoman reported.
Timeline
- Jan 1, 2019Loss dates in the residential claim files reviewed by the Insurance Department run from this date through Dec 31, 2024.
- Nov 1, 2023Start of the period, through Dec 31, 2024, in which the department found at least 22 failures to comply with the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act.
- Nov 13, 2026The department releases the examination in Oklahoma City and State Farm agrees to a settlement worth more than $45 million, with a reopening process for eligible claims closed without payment between Jan 1, 2021 and Dec 31, 2025.
Sources
- Oklahoma Insurance Department: Mulready Announces More Than $45 Million in State Farm Settlement Following Extensive Roof Claims Investigation
- The Oklahoman: State Farm agrees to $45M+ settlement over Oklahoma roof claim denials
- KFOR via Insurance News Net: State Farm settles for more than $45 million following investigation into Oklahoma roof damage claims
- Oklahoma City Focal: State Farm to Pay $45M After Oklahoma Probe Finds Wind, Hail Claims Wrongly Denied