Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
Tech

Meta Warns WhatsApp Could Leave Canada Over Bill C-22

Meta privacy director Robyn Greene told the Senate national security committee on Monday that Bill C-22 cannot be met while keeping end-to-end encryption secure. Asked about pulling WhatsApp, public policy director Rachel Curran said the company would have to consider it.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Meta Warns WhatsApp Could Leave Canada Over Bill C-22

Key points

  • Meta told Canadian senators on Monday evening that it would have to consider pulling its encrypted services, including WhatsApp, from Canada if the federal lawful access bill passes without more…
  • Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told the Senate national security committee that complying with Bill C-22 while still offering secure end-to-end encrypted services is…
  • Meta has not announced a shutdown or a date.

Meta told Canadian senators on Monday evening that it would have to consider pulling its encrypted services, including WhatsApp, from Canada if the federal lawful access bill passes without more changes.

Robyn Greene, Meta's director of privacy and public policy, told the Senate national security committee that complying with Bill C-22 while still offering secure end-to-end encrypted services is not technically feasible. Asked if Meta could pull services from the country, Rachel Curran, the company's Canadian public policy director, said it would have to review all of its options, and that withdrawal is something it would have to consider. She pointed to Apple's decision to pull an encrypted iCloud feature from the United Kingdom.

Meta has not announced a shutdown or a date. The warning is conditional, and it lands at the last stage where the bill can still be changed. Bill C-22 passed the House of Commons in June and is now before the Senate.

What the bill would do

The bill would require tech companies to be able to hand information to investigators with a warrant. It would also let a minister issue confidential orders requiring providers to build surveillance capabilities into their systems. Government amendments cap mandatory metadata retention at six months, down from a year. Ottawa says the bill does not require backdoors and does not give investigators direct access to company systems.

Meta was not alone at the hearing. Signal has said it would leave Canada if the bill passes, and its representatives made the same case on Monday, alongside Tailscale and other tech firms. Apple told CBC News that the amended bill still risks undermining its privacy and security features. Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne, in a November 2 Senate statement, welcomed improvements in the bill but asked for a narrower definition of subscriber information and tighter limits on who can be required to disclose it, under a lower reasonable-suspicion threshold.

Why it matters

WhatsApp is the daily messaging app for a large share of Canadians, including many who use it to talk with family abroad. A fight over encryption in Ottawa is therefore not an abstract policy debate. If the Senate passes the bill as written, companies will have to choose between redesigning their systems for one country, weakening the encryption their users rely on, or leaving. Signal has already named its choice. Meta has now put its own version of that choice on the record, in public, before the final vote.

The government case is that police need modern tools as evidence moves into encrypted apps. The company case is that a built-in access point cannot be kept safe from criminals and hostile states. The Senate committee is the last place where that gap can be narrowed before the bill becomes law.

Timeline

  1. Mar 12, 2026Bill C-22, the lawful access bill, is introduced in Ottawa.
  2. Jun 18, 2026The bill passes the House of Commons with government amendments and goes to the Senate.
  3. Nov 16, 2026Meta, Signal, Tailscale and other tech firms argue against the bill at a Senate national security committee hearing. Meta says it would have to consider pulling encrypted services if the bill passes unchanged.

Sources