Wednesday, November 18, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
US

Indiana Supreme Court Lets Senate Leader Garten Take Oath

The Indiana Supreme Court ruled Tuesday that Sen. Chris Garten can take the oath and be seated, vacating part of a judge's order in his 297-vote race. The block on certifying the District 45 results stays in place, and a hearing on an injunction is set for Wednesday.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Indiana Supreme Court Lets Senate Leader Garten Take Oath
Photo: w_lemay, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Indiana_Statehouse,_Capitol_Avenue,_Indianapolis,_IN_-_53384541176.jpg)

Key points

  • The Indiana Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday morning that Sen.
  • Republican state Sen.
  • Special Judge Jason Mount of Scott County Circuit Court issued the temporary restraining order on Monday, November 16.

Updated 19:50 UTC, November 17

The Indiana Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday morning that Sen. Chris Garten can take the oath of office and be seated as the senator from District 45. Chief Justice Loretta Rush signed the order, and all five justices agreed. The order vacated only the part of the temporary restraining order that barred Garten from presenting himself to take the oath or be seated. It did not lift the block on certifying the election results, and the lower court case continues while the Supreme Court considers Garten's petition. Rush cited the state constitution provision that the respective houses of the legislature are the sole judges of the results of the elections of their members. Garten leads Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, about two-thirds of a percentage point, according to the Indiana secretary of state's office. A hearing on the Democrats' request for a preliminary injunction is set for November 18.

Republican state Sen. Chris Garten could not take the oath of office on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, after a judge barred him from being seated for a new term in Indiana Senate District 45. On November 17, Garten asked the Indiana Supreme Court to intervene, filing a petition for a writ of mandamus and prohibition against the judge who issued the order. The Supreme Court docket showed no determination yet.

Special Judge Jason Mount of Scott County Circuit Court issued the temporary restraining order on Monday, November 16. The order bars Garten from taking the oath or being seated at the November 17 Organization Day ceremonies, when lawmakers gathered in Indianapolis for the start of the 2027 session. Senate Republicans had planned to elect Garten as Senate President Pro Tempore, the top position in the chamber, on Organization Day. Because of the order, he could not be sworn in at all.

The order and the lawsuit behind it

The order states: "Chris Garten is restrained from presenting himself to take the oath of office as, or to be seated as, the Senator from District 45." It also restrains the Clark County Election Board and the Clerk of the Clark Circuit Court from certifying the results of the November 3 general election in the race until the court decides on a preliminary injunction.

The order came out of a lawsuit filed early on Monday, November 16, by Clark County Democratic Party Chair Miguel Hampton. The case, Hampton v. Clark County Election Board et al., case 10C01-2611-MI-192, challenges certification of both the Senate District 45 race and the Clark County auditor's race. Mount, a Democrat, was assigned as special judge after a Clark County judge recused from the case. On November 17, Garten also filed motions to change the judge and to dissolve the restraining order.

A race decided by 297 votes

Garten leads Democratic challenger Nick Marshall by 297 votes, 21,817 to 21,520, a margin of about two thirds of a percentage point. District 45 covers all of Clark County and part of Floyd County.

Democrats argue that voting equipment problems at four precincts voting at Jeffersonville High School leave the results in doubt. One malfunctioning machine, which was replaced on Election Day, recorded 28 more votes than the number of voters checked in on the poll book.

The Clark County Election Board, controlled 2 to 1 by Republicans, voted on November 10 to pass resolutions finding no sufficient factual basis for recounting the ballots. The board had initially planned a hand count of ballots from the polling place with the malfunctioning machine, and then reversed course.

What happens next

The restraining order stays in effect for no longer than 10 days. A hearing on the Democrats' request for a preliminary injunction is scheduled for 1:15 p.m. on Wednesday, November 18, in Jeffersonville. That hearing will decide whether the block on seating and certification continues while the case goes forward.

Democrats say they intend to seek a recount of the Senate race. Candidates had until Tuesday, November 17 to file recount petitions, and county party chairs have until Friday. The party said on November 16 that it had not yet filed for a recount.

Timeline

  1. Nov 3, 2026General election in Senate District 45. Garten finishes ahead of Marshall by 297 votes, 21,817 to 21,520.
  2. Nov 10, 2026The Clark County Election Board votes to pass resolutions finding no sufficient factual basis for recounting the ballots.
  3. Nov 16, 2026Miguel Hampton files suit challenging certification, and Judge Jason Mount issues a temporary restraining order barring Garten from taking the oath or being seated.
  4. Nov 17, 2026Organization Day in Indianapolis. Garten cannot be sworn in, files motions against the order, and petitions the Indiana Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus and prohibition.
  5. Nov 18, 2026Hearing on the request for a preliminary injunction, scheduled for 1:15 p.m. in Jeffersonville.
  6. Nov 17, 2026The Indiana Supreme Court, in an order signed by Chief Justice Loretta Rush and agreed by all five justices, vacates the part of the restraining order barring Garten from taking the oath and being seated. The block on certifying the District 45 results remains, and an injunction hearing is set for November 18.

Sources