ICC Judges Close US Troops Line of Afghanistan Investigation, Leaving Only Taliban Probe
Judges at the International Criminal Court in The Hague have formally closed the part of the Afghanistan investigation that looked at alleged crimes by US troops and by ISIS-K. The active case now covers only alleged Taliban crimes since 2021, and arrest warrants for four Taliban leaders remain in effect.
Key points
- Judges at the International Criminal Court in The Hague have formally closed part of the prosecutor's Afghanistan investigations that previously looked at alleged crimes by US troops, court…
- The chamber's decision formally closes the line of inquiry into alleged crimes by US troops.
- The Taliban strand remains active.
Judges at the International Criminal Court in The Hague have formally closed part of the prosecutor's Afghanistan investigations that previously looked at alleged crimes by US troops, court documents show. The active Afghanistan probe at the court now focuses only on actions of the Taliban since 2021.
What the chamber closed
The chamber's decision formally closes the line of inquiry into alleged crimes by US troops. That line had already lain dormant since 2021, so the ruling ends a strand of the case that prosecutors had not actively pursued for five years. The decision also formally closes the line of inquiry into the Islamic State Khorasan militia, known as ISIS-K. Both closures take the strands of the Afghanistan work that did not concern the Taliban off the court's active list.
What remains open
The Taliban strand remains active. Earlier this year, judges ordered prosecutors to split the Afghanistan inquiries into two separate probes. One probe covers alleged Taliban crimes since 2021. The other was the original inquiry, which also looked at alleged war crimes by US troops and had shifted toward ISIS-K. Because the cases were split in that way, the arrest warrants issued against four Afghan Taliban leaders remain in effect, and the closure of the second probe does not change their status.
Why the judges acted
Judges said they closed part of the case because prosecutors had not shown they would be able to effectively investigate allegations in Afghanistan apart from the Taliban probe. On that reasoning, the court kept the strand that could still be pursued and closed the strands that prosecutors had not shown they could investigate in practice. The office of the prosecutor told Reuters on Friday that it had appealed the decision. The office could not give further details about the appeal, so the grounds of the challenge and the timetable for any ruling are not yet public.
Sanctions and the wider dispute
The decision is the latest step in a legal dispute between prosecutors and judges over the Afghanistan case. It comes after the United States imposed institutional sanctions on the court. The United States cited its opposition to arrest warrants for Israeli officials and to the investigation into actions of US soldiers in Afghanistan. Reuters reported that it is unclear whether formally closing part of the Afghanistan case will be enough to ease American concerns about the court asserting jurisdiction over US nationals. The ruling does not change the court's founding statute. That statute says the court can prosecute anyone accused of atrocity crimes committed on the territory of ICC member states, so the legal basis that concerned Washington remains in the text of the statute even after this closure.
Timeline
- 2021The line of inquiry into alleged crimes by US troops lies dormant from this year. Taliban actions from 2021 onward later form the scope of the probe that survives.
- 2026Judges order prosecutors to split the Afghanistan inquiries into two probes: one on alleged Taliban crimes since 2021, and the original inquiry, which also looked at alleged war crimes by US troops and had shifted toward ISIS-K.
- Nov 13, 2026Judges formally close the US troops and ISIS-K lines of inquiry, leaving only the Taliban probe active. The prosecutor's office tells Reuters it has appealed, and arrest warrants against four Taliban leaders remain in effect.