Thursday, November 19, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
US

Des Moines, Iowa: Supreme Court Reinstates James Wiggins Murder Conviction in Rico's Bar Shooting

The Iowa Supreme Court ruled Friday that a uniformed deputy seated behind James Wiggins as he testified did not deny him a fair trial, canceling the new trial an appeals court had ordered in the 2022 Rico's bar killing of Tyrone Hutchins.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Des Moines, Iowa: Supreme Court Reinstates James Wiggins Murder Conviction in Rico's Bar Shooting
Photo: Paul R. Burley, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Iowa_Judicial_Branch_Building_Des_Moines_2019-1925.jpg)

Key points

  • James Wiggins will not get a new trial.
  • Rico's, on University Avenue in the Drake University Dogtown district, has since closed.
  • Wiggins testified that he acted in self defense against an onrushing, armed Hutchins and had heard a shot fired first.

James Wiggins will not get a new trial. The Iowa Supreme Court ruled on Friday, Nov. 13 that a uniformed sheriff's deputy seated near Wiggins as he testified did not violate his right to a fair trial, and the court reinstated his second degree murder conviction in the December 2022 shooting death of Tyrone Hutchins at Rico's bar in Des Moines.

The shooting at Rico's

Rico's, on University Avenue in the Drake University Dogtown district, has since closed. Evidence at trial showed Wiggins and his brother Marcell came to the bar in December 2022, where Marcell, who had a gun, got into a dispute with Hutchins, a man the brothers had disagreed with before. James Wiggins stayed by the door and, as Hutchins, also armed, retreated toward the exit, shot him twice and grazed a bystander.

Wiggins testified that he acted in self defense against an onrushing, armed Hutchins and had heard a shot fired first. Prosecutors answered that only Wiggins' gun was fired and that video showed him drawing and racking his pistol before entering the building. Wiggins was arrested in early 2024. A Polk County jury convicted him that August of second degree murder, rejecting his claim of justification, and he was sentenced to 50 years in prison and ordered to pay $150,000 in victim restitution.

The deputy by the witness stand

Wiggins was in custody during the trial, and a uniformed deputy sat behind him while he testified. No deputy had been stationed there for the state's witnesses. On May 13, 2026, the Iowa Court of Appeals reversed the conviction and ordered a new trial, finding the armed guard's presence could have led jurors to inferences that, in Judge John Sandy's words, could certainly be negative toward the defendant. The state appealed, and the justices heard argument on Oct. 2.

What the supreme court said

Justice Edward Mansfield wrote for a unanimous court. A security officer's presence, he wrote, can be perceived as standard practice rather than a marker of guilt, unlike prison clothes or shackles. Judges, the court held, need not find a particular defendant dangerous to justify a deputy's presence. Mansfield wrote that the security was meant to be unobtrusive: the deputy did not accompany the defendant to the stand in the jury's presence and sat in a corner behind it. The court added: "We have difficulty seeing that the mere presence of a deputy for security purposes would have moved the needle toward a guilty verdict, and certainly there is nothing specific in the record to suggest it did."

The justices affirmed the conviction and the 50 year sentence, with one exception. They struck down the part of the sentence ordering Wiggins to take part in a victim-offender dialogue, finding it was not legally authorized, and sent the case back only to remove that provision. The Polk County Attorney's Office had told the Des Moines Register it intended to retry Wiggins if the appeals court decision stood. Wiggins' attorney did not respond to a message seeking comment. His brother Marcell pleaded guilty to going armed with intent and is serving a 30 year sentence in connection with the killing and separate drug offenses, after fleeing Iowa and being returned for sentencing earlier this year.

The second Rico's case

Hutchins was one of two men shot to death in or near Rico's in 2022, both by men who later claimed self defense. Andrew Harris was convicted of second degree murder for killing Tyrell Grimes outside the bar and is serving 60 years. On Nov. 4, the Court of Appeals rejected Harris' appeal.

Timeline

  1. Dec 2022James Wiggins shoots Tyrone Hutchins twice at Rico's bar on University Avenue in Des Moines. Hutchins dies.
  2. Aug 2024A Polk County jury convicts Wiggins of second degree murder. He is sentenced to 50 years in prison.
  3. May 13, 2026The Iowa Court of Appeals vacates the conviction and orders a new trial, finding that a uniformed deputy seated near Wiggins as he testified could have prejudiced the jury.
  4. Nov 13, 2026The Iowa Supreme Court vacates the appeals court decision and reinstates the conviction, striking only the victim-offender dialogue part of the sentence.

Sources