Dallas, Texas: Darlie Routier Files Habeas Bid Citing New DNA and Fingerprint Tests
Lawyers for the Rowlett mother on Texas death row filed a writ of habeas corpus in Dallas County on Thursday, November 19. The filing cites DNA from an unidentified man on a bloody sock and fingerprints that match neither Routier nor her then husband.
Key points
- Attorneys for Darlie Routier filed a new application for a writ of habeas corpus in Dallas County on Thursday, November 19, asking the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to send her case back to…
- Routier was convicted in 1997 of killing her 5 year old son, Damon, and sentenced to death.
- The filing says advanced DNA testing found genetic material from an unidentified man on a bloody sock recovered in an alley behind the Routier home.
Attorneys for Darlie Routier filed a new application for a writ of habeas corpus in Dallas County on Thursday, November 19, asking the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals to send her case back to district court for new hearings. The filing was submitted by the Innocence Project and the Texas Office of Capital and Forensic Writs. It does not overturn her conviction and it does not grant her a new trial. It asks the appeals court to let a district court hear evidence her lawyers say was not available at her trial.
Routier was convicted in 1997 of killing her 5 year old son, Damon, and sentenced to death. Her 6 year old son, Devin, was also killed that night in the family home in Rowlett in 1996, but prosecutors kept the two cases separate and did not pursue a second trial after the first conviction. She has spent nearly 30 years on Texas death row and has maintained that an intruder broke into the home, killed both boys and injured her before escaping.
DNA on a bloody sock
The filing says advanced DNA testing found genetic material from an unidentified man on a bloody sock recovered in an alley behind the Routier home. Her lawyers say that test was not available in 1996. The sock carried blood from the boys and was a central piece of evidence in the original case. The new result, the petition argues, points to an unknown man and undercuts the prosecution theory that no intruder was there.
New fingerprint analyses in the petition reach a similar result. Prints on a knife blade and on a utility room door, including one print in blood, do not match Routier or her then husband, Darin, according to an affidavit submitted with the filing. The analyses also excluded both of them as the source of a fingerprint on the knife blade. The findings do not identify who left the prints.
Five claims, and a challenge to the staging theory
The lawyers ask the Court of Criminal Appeals to authorize review of five claims. They cover new scientific evidence, alleged false testimony, withheld evidence, alleged due process violations and actual innocence. The filing also questions a piece of the state case from the trial. Microscopic fiberglass strands found on the murder weapon were used by prosecutors to argue that Routier staged the attack. The petition says those strands may have come from an investigator fingerprint brush instead.
"Darlie Routier has spent nearly 30 years on Texas death row for a crime someone else committed, and of which she was a victim," defense attorney Vanessa Potkin said in a statement. "There's a wealth of newly available forensic evidence that supports Ms. Routier's innocence and dismantles the false narrative the state used to wrongfully convict Ms. Routier. We also now know that the state suppressed exculpatory evidence and presented false testimony at trial."
At trial, the state said Routier killed her sons and then slashed her own neck in a staged attack. Her previous two appeals were rejected. Both focused on trial records and legal proceedings, not on new DNA evidence. The Court of Criminal Appeals has not ruled on the new filing. If it orders a remand, a district court would hold evidentiary hearings on the new testing and the other claims.
Timeline
- 1996Damon Routier, 5, and Devin Routier, 6, are killed in the family home in Rowlett. A bloody sock is recovered in an alley behind the home.
- 1997A jury convicts Darlie Routier of the murder of Damon and sentences her to death. Prosecutors do not pursue a second trial for Devin.
- Nov 19, 2026The Innocence Project and the Texas Office of Capital and Forensic Writs file a writ of habeas corpus in Dallas County citing new DNA and fingerprint testing, and ask the Court of Criminal Appeals to remand the case to district court.