Friday, November 20, 2026 Editions
Latest
Trending
US

Lake Elmo, Minnesota Driver Sentenced to More Than Two Years in Highway 36 Crash That Killed 5 Year Old Girl

Jeffrey Dean Alexander Jr. was sentenced on Thursday in Washington County for the January 2024 crash on Highway 36 that killed Morgan Petersen, 5, whose family car had stalled in the left lane at Lake Elmo Avenue.

Read inENESNEHIFR
Lake Elmo, Minnesota Driver Sentenced to More Than Two Years in Highway 36 Crash That Killed 5 Year Old Girl

Key points

  • A Washington County judge on Thursday sentenced Jeffrey Dean Alexander Jr.
  • The crash happened at about 8:45 p.m. on Jan. 20, 2024, on eastbound Highway 36 at Lake Elmo Avenue.
  • Alexander, driving a Nissan Pathfinder, came up behind the stalled car and hit it.

A Washington County judge on Thursday sentenced Jeffrey Dean Alexander Jr. to more than two years in prison for the Highway 36 crash that killed 5 year old Morgan Petersen, closing the court case close to three years after her family's stalled car was hit from behind in Lake Elmo.

A stalled car in the left lane

The crash happened at about 8:45 p.m. on Jan. 20, 2024, on eastbound Highway 36 at Lake Elmo Avenue. The Petersen family's Ford Focus, driven by Morgan's father, Christopher Petersen, stalled with a mechanical problem in the left lane. Morgan, 5, was riding in the back seat, and a 10 year old boy was also in the car.

Alexander, driving a Nissan Pathfinder, came up behind the stalled car and hit it. Both vehicles took extensive damage. Morgan was taken to Regions Hospital in St. Paul, where she died the next day. Her father and the 10 year old were also taken to Regions Hospital for treatment.

Speed, alcohol and a missed hazard

State Patrol reconstruction put the Pathfinder at 81 mph five seconds before the crash and 75 mph four seconds before impact, in a stretch of Highway 36 with a 65 mph limit. It was still going 62 to 63 mph when it hit. A driver traveling ahead of Alexander changed lanes to avoid the stalled Ford. Alexander did not.

The road was clear and dry that night, and investigators said the Ford's flashing hazard lights could have been seen from about a quarter mile away. A blood sample taken a few hours after the crash put Alexander's blood alcohol concentration at 0.056 and also found clonazepam, a prescription medication he was authorized to take.

The State Patrol listed four contributing factors: Alexander failed to recognize the hazard the stalled car created, he was speeding, he was impaired by alcohol and clonazepam, and he was not leaving enough distance to react to hazards in the road.

Two counts and a sentence

Alexander was charged by summons with two counts of criminal vehicular homicide. One count said he drove in a grossly negligent manner. The other said he drove with negligence while under the influence of a combination of alcohol and a controlled substance. On Thursday, in Washington County, he was sentenced to more than two years in prison. The first reports of the sentencing did not publish the exact term.

She had a huge heart

Christopher Petersen told KSTP he will always remember a daughter who wanted to help people she saw along the road. "She had a huge heart," he said. "She always wanted to help other people out." He recalled that when Morgan saw a person with a sign who looked cold, she would press him to give them a blanket, some food or some money.

Timeline

  1. Jan 20, 2024The Petersen family's Ford Focus stalls in the left lane of eastbound Highway 36 at Lake Elmo Avenue at about 8:45 p.m. and is hit from behind by a Nissan Pathfinder.
  2. Jan 21, 2024Morgan Petersen, 5, dies at Regions Hospital in St. Paul from her injuries.
  3. Nov 12, 2026Jeffrey Dean Alexander Jr. is sentenced in Washington County to more than two years in prison.

Sources